Teaching chemical engineering thermodynamics with ChETL
A practical guide for instructors: what ChETL can contribute to a thermodynamics course, a reusable classroom workflow built on the platform and the published P–xy worked example, three ways to fit it into teaching, and the limits to explain to students.
What ChETL can contribute to a course
ChETL is a learning platform, not a replacement for a lecturer or a textbook. It is most useful where students need to see how a method turns into numbers and what those numbers mean. For any case a student configures, it provides:
- a written Theory chapter and solution strategy for the topic;
- a Blackboard: the complete numerical working, with every known, its source, each substitution and units;
- a plot over a range of conditions with the configured state marked, and the data table behind it (copy, CSV or Excel);
- an Interpretation of the result, ending with validity and limitations;
- an AI Tutor for follow-up questions about that case, and short Assessment question sets;
- a printable PDF of the Blackboard.
The topics available are listed on the course map. ChETL does not provide gradebook or learning-management-system integration, and this guide does not assume any instructor dashboard. This website does not publish pricing, licensing or institutional-access terms; for course or departmental use, write to the project.
Aligning with your learning outcomes
Start from what students should be able to do, then choose the surface that exercises it. The examples refer to the published P–xy worked example.
| Students should be able to… | Use | P–xy example |
|---|---|---|
| recall definitions, symbols and governing equations | Theory; Assessment at Remembering level | bubble and dew points; modified Raoult’s law |
| calculate a result by a stated method | Blackboard, reproduced by hand | bubble pressure from γ and Psat |
| explain physical meaning and trends | Interpretation; Plot; Assessment at Comprehension level | why the first vapour is richer in ethanol |
| choose a model and justify it | Theory solution strategy; changing the model and comparing | Raoult’s law versus modified Raoult’s law |
| judge what a result does and does not support | Interpretation limits; discussion | why a fixed-temperature diagram cannot size a column |
| apply the concept to a bounded new situation | Assessment at Application level; new configurations | another temperature or composition |
A reusable class workflow: predict, calculate, inspect, vary, explain
This sequence works for most topics and for a single class or a week of study. Each phase is illustrated with the ethanol–water P–xy case: an equimolar liquid at 343.15 K, modified Raoult’s law, NRTL with library parameters, bubble-pressure target.
-
Predict
Before any calculation, ask students to commit to an expectation and a reason. Will the bubble pressure lie above or below the straight Raoult’s-law line between the two pure-component vapour pressures? Will the first vapour be richer or poorer in ethanol than the liquid? Written predictions make the later comparison meaningful.
-
Calculate
Run the configured case: in the platform under Phase Equilibrium › P–xy (ETHANOL and WATER, Modified Raoult, NRTL, Library parameters, target Bubble, 343.15 K, x1 = 0.5), or by stepping through the worked example’s Blackboard viewer in class. Everyone using the same configuration sees the same engine result, which makes whole-class comparison easy.
-
Inspect
Read the Blackboard line by line. Which values are given, which come from a database, and with what units and ranges? Ask students to reproduce one step by hand, such as an activity coefficient or a K value, and to check the closure Σyi = 1. This is where errors of units and conventions surface.
-
Vary
Change one thing at a time and record what moves: temperature, liquid composition, the formulation (Raoult’s law against modified Raoult’s law), or the activity model where parameters exist. The platform reports a combination it cannot calculate as unavailable instead of substituting another model, which is itself worth discussing.
-
Explain
Ask for a short written explanation of the result and of one variation, then compare it with the Interpretation tab. Students can take open questions to the AI Tutor, and finish with an Assessment set in Interactive Learning mode for immediate feedback.
The same five phases apply to other topics: for example, predicting whether Z is above or below one for a vapour, or whether pressure should favour the products of a gas-phase reaction, before calculating.
Three ways to use it
- Live demonstration
- Project the workspace in a lecture. Take predictions, calculate, then change inputs in response to students’ questions. The Blackboard replaces hand-written arithmetic on the board, leaving time for reasoning about choices and results.
- Flipped preparation
- Ask students to read the topic’s Theory, or the worked example, before class and to bring one prediction and one question. Class time then goes to the inspect, vary and explain phases.
- Independent study and tutorials
- Students work through a topic alone, use Interactive Learning for feedback, and bring difficulties to a tutorial. Classroom Simulation gives them a timed, independent attempt with review afterwards.
Assessment: what it offers and what it does not
- Levels: Remembering, Comprehension and Application.
- Modes: Interactive Learning (each answer marked at once with an explanation) and Classroom Simulation (no feedback until the set is complete, then a results summary and a review of each question).
- Question supply: questions may be AI-generated for the active topic and case and are screened by automated checks; a curated set for the topic is used when generation fails. They are not human-reviewed.
- Results are shown to the student in the session. They are not sent to a gradebook, and ChETL does not claim measured learning gains.
Use ChETL’s assessment for formative practice. For marks that count, set your own questions; the workflow above, with its predictions, hand-checked steps and written explanations, gives natural material for them.
Using the published worked example
The ethanol–water P–xy worked example is an ordinary web page that students can read without an account. It contains the problem and its configured inputs, a short theory section with learning outcomes, the model equations, a four-step Blackboard viewer, the P–xy diagram, four interpretation cards, a list of assumptions and limits, a check-your-understanding question with explained answers, and its sources and review record.
- Before class: set the problem and theory sections as reading, with the check question at the end.
- In class: step through the Blackboard viewer, then open the platform and vary the case.
- After class: the page offers the Blackboard as a PDF, the plotted data as CSV and the plot as SVG. Students can verify one exported curve point against the equations in the lesson.
- On paper: the page prints with every step and card shown.
Discussion prompts
These questions use only the published case and its stated limits. They work for seminars or short written responses.
- The first-vapour composition is y1 = 0.6626. Why is this not the composition of the vapour you would collect from a flash drum at a lower pressure?
- Why can the x–y curve from a fixed-temperature diagram not be used to step off stages for a column operating at constant pressure?
- The calculation treats the vapour as an ideal gas. Why is that reasonable here, and what would a γ–φ formulation add?
- The diagram shows a pressure maximum near x1 ≈ 0.9 on a finite grid. What can and cannot be concluded about an azeotrope?
- The NRTL parameters come from a library source with a stated temperature range. What would change in your confidence if the case were outside that range?
- What separates the bubble pressure from a design pressure for a storage tank or pump suction?
Limits to explain to students
- Results are model estimates for learning. They depend on the model, the parameters and their ranges, and they are not design values.
- Agreement is not validation. A result that matches a reference calculation shows the equations were solved, not that the model fits the real system.
- The AI Tutor can be wrong. Its answers are generated dynamically and may be inaccurate; important conclusions should be checked against the Theory, the calculated results and cited references.
- Each module has stated boundaries. For example, Phase Equilibrium covers vapour–liquid equilibrium only, and Chemical Equilibrium covers gas-phase reactions treated as ideal-gas mixtures. The course scope lists them.
Practical notes
- Students sign in at app.chetl.org; the public website, including the worked example and these guides, needs no account. The getting started guide covers first use.
- The AI Tutor has a daily question allowance per user, so plan class activities around the workspace rather than around many Tutor questions.
- The Blackboard PDF and the data export make it straightforward to collect working alongside students’ own calculations.
- Ready-made activity packs, student handouts and further worked examples are not yet published; the workflow above uses the platform and the existing example only.
Feedback and corrections
Reports from teaching are especially useful: a step students misread, a result that looks wrong, or a topic that would benefit from clearer explanation. Email info@chetl.org with the page or topic, the step and what you observed. Scientific corrections follow the route on Contact.